Book Reviews

Nevernight Book Review.


Jay Kristoff.

4 stars out of 5.


Book Blurb:

Destined to destroy empires, Mia Corvere is only ten years old when she is given her first lesson in death.

Six years later, the child raised in shadows takes her first steps towards keeping the promise she made on the day she lost everything.

But the chance to strike against such powerful enemies will be fleeting, so if she is to have her revenge, Mia must become a weapon without equal. She must prove herself against the deadliest of friends and enemies, and survive the tutelage of murderers, liars and daemons at the heart of a murder cult.

The Red Church is no ordinary school, but Mia is no ordinary student.
The shadows love her.
And they drink her fear.

Book Review:

I received a free copy of this book courtesy of the publisher in exchange for an honest review.

In short, Nevernight is the first book in Jay Kristoff’s new fantasy trilogy focusing on Mia Corvere who along with her companion the ‘shadow cat’ Mr Kindly sets out to be accepted by and graduate the Red Church to become a fully fledged blade (assassin) so she can get her vengeance and revenge on those who killed her family.

Nevernight starts with perhaps one of the best opening lines in recent history for fantasy or any other genre of book. Perfectly setting the tone for the language and writing style for the entirety of the novel.

People often shit themselves when they die, did you know that?

The writing for the most part in Nevernight is really good but some may find Kristoff’s style slightly different to begin with and it may take readers a while to get into. Kristoff manages to pull you into the story with descriptive, vivid prose and viscerally gore splattered well written combat scenes. But at times, it also feels likes he’s giving you slightly to much information, along with the story there’s also footnotes that appear throughout the book. There isn’t many in the second half of the book but in the first half there seems at times to be an awful lot clogging up the pages. That’s not to say that they aren’t a decent addition, they add extra history and lore to the story, aswell as being observational musings that are often quite sarcastic, amusing and humorous.

It’s perhaps hard to classify Nevernight, it’s part revenge tale and part coming of age story. But, while it’s central focus is on Mia and some would say it’s a character driven story it’s a bit to action centric for me to be simply classified as character driven and it falls somewhere between both being a character driven and story driven book.

The pacing however in Nevernight is slightly off at times and I found the book to drag in places. It’s not boring or slow which probably sounds weird after I’ve just wrote it drags. But there just seemed to be too much going on and you were thrown from one confrontation and event to the next with minimal time in between to take things in. Sometimes, lack of action, taking a step back and replacing it with character introspection adds far more emotion and atmosphere to the overall story than yet something else occurring, another layer and plot thread being added just for the sake of it.

Ecspecially in fantasy it’s not all about the action and events taking place and it’s more about the calm before the storm, the quiet introspective and reflective moments and/or even the deathly silence of the aftermath that hold the real meaning. And, I’d have liked to have seen more of those sedate moments as they were very fleeting and seemed few and far between throughout the books 600 page length.

During the book I knew one of the plot twists a mile away – standard fantasy trope, it’s never the obvious culprit! But for the other major twist, I fully admit that I didn’t see it coming and was shocked. The twist itself was a welcome addition to the story though, breathing new life into the book as it had started to drag in places before the surprise twist. And, with 100 pages left the twist propelled the story forward setting Nevernight up for its epic conclusion and finale.

I mentioned humour earlier in the footnotes. I found the humour throughout Nevernight to be top quality from the occasional sarcastic remark by characters to the laugh out loud comments strewn throughout, often finding myself sniggering at what I was reading. High praise also to Krisroff for his usage of the word ‘funbags’ it’s not a word I ever imagined that I’d read in a fantasy novel! Mr Kindly’s observations and Ashlinn’s comments during Mia’s time at the Red Church are highlights of the book making you laugh at Mr Kindly’s drollness and Ash’s often lewd and bawdy remarks, giving you some at times needed comic relief.

For me, one of the best things about the book is the world building, it’s richly detailed throughout with plenty of magic, culture, religion (light and dark), history and lore depicting a vividly realised world and shows real thought on Kristoff’s part. It’s easy to see that he’s spent a lot of time and effort envisioning his created world and bringing it to the pages. The Red Church is great, a school shadowed in darkness to make the world’s deadliest assassin’s surrounded by the Ashkahi Whisperwastes, a barren nightmarish wasteland inhabited by Sand Krakens, foul creatures with gaping maws and a thirst for anything trespassing in their domain, even vile creatures need their Nom Nom’s! Godsgrave is also a vast well realised city and the Philosopher’s Stone is depicted as a terrifying prison for the worst of society with no hope of escape.

The characterisation for the main core characters in Nevernight is for the most part top notch, you get back story, motives and understand the reasoning behind the actions they take. Let’s be honest, it’s a blood soaked revenge tale and you would need a very good/dark reason to want to be an assassin! Mia being the main character and focal point of the story has the most character development but other apprentices at the Red Church like, Tric, Carlotta, Jessamine and Ashlinn are all well thought out with their reasonings being valid and the characters themselves being a welcome part of the story. I’d have liked to have seen some back story for the Shahiid’s (Reverend Mother Drusilla, Spiderkiller, Solis, Aalea and Mouser) at the Red Church along with The Weaver Marielle and her brother The Speaker Adonai as I feel that would have been really interesting, hearing and finding out about some of the assassinations that they had taken part in. Likewise, reading about the enigma that is the Lord of Blade’s himself, Lord Cassius would also have been nice, even if it was just one of the Shahiid’s regaling the apprentices with one of his kills during one of their lessons.

Back to Mia, she’s a great choice for the story to revolve around, unfortunately she suffers from another quite standard fantasy trope whereby she has memory loss of a traumatic event, that we find out about later in the story was in fact not the nightmares she has (Mr Kindly her shadowy companion keeps her fear at bay) but forgotten reality. This results in Mia’s dark/shadow powers coming to the fore and being far more powerful than they previously had been. Mia is a ‘darkin’ which sadly we don’t learn much more about in the book other than the actual ‘darkin’ name. Hopefully Kristoff will delve deeper into the darkin kind and explain more in future books.

As a gamer I couldn’t help but feel that some of Mia’s abilities were very reminiscent to the computer games – The Darkness 1 and 2. The main character in them controls the darkness often using tendrils born from the darkness and has darkling minions. Similar to how Mia does with shadow, using her shadow tendrils and her shadow companion. On a whole, it’s completely irrelevant to the book, story or this review, but for me, it was cool when reading the book to remember a couple of games I played years ago.

I’d like to have my say in what genre I’d actually class Nevernight as. A few websites have it classified as Y-A in the listing and also, after reading a few other reviews they to say Nevernight is Y-A merely because Mia is a young main character (10 years old when tragedy occurs and 16 years old for most of the book). Apologies, but I have to disagree, a young protagonist doesn’t immediately mean that the book is Y-A, ecspecially not in fantasy. I’m sure my fellow fantasy fans out there will agree with me that it’s a quite standard fantasy trope – start the series with a young main character who’s orphaned, lost, abandoned, stolen and sold into slavery, etc and then they age, growing older as the story progresses through each respective book in the series. A few examples I will give you are: Assassins Apprentice by Robin Hobb, the first book in The Farseer trilogy. Fitz, the main character and focus of the trilogy is a young boy, younger than Mia when the book starts. Blood Song (Raven’s Shadow book 1) by Anthony Ryan, Vaelin Al Sorna is also young when the series starts. Corban in John Gwynne’s Malice (The Faithful and the Fallen series book 1) is again a youngster. So, as you can see, it’s a standard trope in a lot of epic fantasy series to have a young central character. Perhaps you could even add Game of Thrones to the list if that’s the way of thinking, young characters = Y-A as lots of the cast in that series are very young when it starts (Bran, Sansa, Arya, Joffrey, Tommen, Mercella and Rickon) – if you’ve only ever watched the TV show, the characters ages were altered to make them older than they are in the books. I’ve saved the best for last in my little meandering diatribe. Prince of Thorns (Broken Empire trilogy book 1) by Mark Lawrence, in this book Jorg Ancrath is yet again another young main character and focal point for the whole series. And, the Broken Empire trilogy is as far from Y-A as you can get, it’s Grimdark fantasy through and through with Jorg making Mia look like a perfectly good, well behaved and mannered kind little girl (there are some similarities between Mia and Jorg I will admit that, but Mia has some occasional feelings and Jorg is completely lacking in any such compunction or morals). So, on the back of my ARC it says:

From the publishers who brought you George R. R. Martin and Robin Hobb, Harper Voyager presents an action-packed and unforgettable new epic fantasy: Nevernight.

And that’s also what Nevernight is to me. With its language, violence, visceral action, sex scenes – two surprisingly quite graphic and explicit. It is epic fantasy and not Y-A.

Nevernight has been very hyped and is being touted with much fanfare as the next big thing in fantasy. And, unfortunately for me, it failed to live upto the hype surrounding it. Yes, it is a decent book but it’s certainly not the greatest fantasy novel ever written.

However, I do think the hype is a good thing as it’s brought the book to a lot of people’s attention who perhaps don’t normally frequent the fantasy genre. And, hopefully after reading Nevernight those readers may broaden their horizons and jump back into another foray into fantasy, as there truly are plenty of great books/series waiting for new readers to delve into their pages and read them!

Now, after writing all that, the question to ask is, did I enjoy Nevernight and would I recommend it to others to read?

And the answer is, on a whole, yes I most definitely would! I really did enjoy Nevernight. On the upside the book contains some really interesting ideas, a good core story, engaging minor characters, a captivating main character in Mia and the last 100 pages fly by in a page turning, epic, blood soaked, action packed finale. But on the downside, I also admit that I did find it at times to be bloated, flawed and overlong. However, it’s certainly a book you can get a lot out of and is well worth your time. And, I’d definitely recommend it to people and my fellow fantasy fans as I myself am looking forward to seeing where Kristoff takes the story in the sequel.

A good start to a new epic fantasy series. Being the first book in a series you’re always going to be left with an inconclusive conclusion to the story and unanswered questions and storylines – it’s the nature of being the first part in a trilogy, you need to wait until the end of the final book for the epic conclusion to the whole story. Kristoff however, finds a decent end point for the book and the ending of Nevernight feels like the end of one part of Mia’s tale and the start of the next. Leaving you intrigued to find out both where the story goes and what next awaits Mia.


I read this book as a buddy read with my fellow blogger and arch American nemesis Filly over at RantandRaveaboutBooks. And soΒ my good people, now that you have finished with my rambled musings, might Β I suggest that you hop on over to her blog and peruse her own take on Nevernight checking out her review. Link can be found: !!HERE!!

Follow me on:

Twitter and Goodreads.



34 thoughts on “Nevernight Book Review.

  1. Yeah, I liked the opening sentence as well! XD Decent review Drew and definitely educated me in some of the fantasy trope things… I normally don’t pay attention to such details, etc but good to know nonetheless! πŸ™‚

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Excellent review, Drew! πŸ™‚ Well, this was fun doing a buddy read with you. I like all the book comparisons. I haven’t read much adult fantasy, mostly YA fantasy, so I didn’t know that was a thing to start off with a young MC. Because of those sex scenes, I couldn’t see considering this book YA. I hope kids don’t read this book. And, I want to know which plot twist you saw coming. You’ll need to email that to me so we don’t spoil the story for anyone reading this comment.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Hmmmmm… Well, if I see Nevernight in a bookstore, I’ll probably pick it up. I think some of my reservation is due to the fact that, while I usually have no problem with violence or sex scenes in fantasy, there comes a point where it’s too much for me. And I’m already wondering if Nevernight will reach that “too much” threshold… But I guess I won’t know for sure unless I read it for myself, right?

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Ah, that’s true.πŸ˜€ I don’t have any problems with violence – it comes with being a Grimdark fan but sex scenes, I don’t mind them however the ones in Nevernight were some of the most graphic I’ve read in the whole ‘fantasy’ genre which surprised me as some people were classing it as Y-A!

      Liked by 1 person

  4. I wouldn’t classify it as YA either, but the Goodreads newsletter did. It was just an okay read for me – great humor in places, meandering focus in others – but you’re right about the hype.

    Liked by 1 person

  5. Excellent review! I feel like I know all I need to about the book now. The truth I mean, not the hype machine. And I think I’ll be skipping this one. It just doesn’t appeal to me. Especially the graphic sex scenes, which must be fairly shocking since some reviewers are saying the author needs to write a smut book next. Not really what I look for in fantasy books.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thankyou, yeah there’s alot of hype for the book and I’m guessing you mean Jill at RantandRaveaboutBooks for the ‘Smut book’ next, they have to be explicit if even Jill thinks that! πŸ˜‚

      The sex scenes for me really are bad, I read alot of fantasy and I’m not a prude. While there’s only 2 in the book, to say it’s classed as Y-A by some they are the most explicit I’ve read in ages, not just a paragraph either, they go on for pages!

      Liked by 1 person

  6. EPIC review!!! I’m happy to hear that it falls more towards epic Fantasy than YA. I’ve heard similar things about his Lotus War series which I own but haven’t gotten around to yet. I’m all for world building & rich characters, from what I gather his writing is unique and may require a bit of patience…sign me up! I’ve pre-ordered my copy from the U.K. & can’t wait to receive it!!! πŸ™‚

    Liked by 1 person

  7. Brilliant a character based on Jackie Estacado is always a great temptation for me to read a book , also how about Kvothe for an example of a young kid in Fantasy , talking of which i judge a book to be Fantasy or YA based on what kind of audience they are trying to target and the world building and attention to detail regarding the said world . A YA delves very little in to darker tales and Morality of Characters a YA . Basically a YA per me is a conscious version of Epic Adult fantasy meant for younger age groups .
    Anyways good review

    Liked by 1 person

  8. Excellent review, Drew. I think you’ve nailed it pretty comprehensively. I loved it. The pace sagged a little in the middle but the opening and closing thirds were a pleasure to read.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thankyou, it was certainly a long review I ended up writing! πŸ™‚ The closing third was great, it really needed hat twist though but then the pages just flew by. πŸ™‚

      Oh, while I remember, thanks for the follow on Twitter to. πŸ™‚


  9. Absolutely brilliant review- really fair and balanced. I’ve seen so many reviews coming down on this book as either amazing or terrible. It’s good to hear that even if it doesn’t live upto hype, it’s still a good book (and good to know that it’s more epic fantasy than YA)

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.