Book Reviews

The Ninth Rain (The Winnowing Flame #1) Book Review

  • The Ninth Rain (The Winnowing Flame #1).
  • Jen Williams.
  • 544 pages.
  • Fantasy / Magic / Epic Fantasy.
  • My Rating: 4.5 stars out of 5.


Book Blurb:

The great city of Ebora once glittered with gold. Now its streets are stalked by wolves. Tormalin the Oathless has no taste for sitting around waiting to die while the realm of his storied ancestors falls to pieces – talk about a guilt trip. Better to be amongst the living, where there are taverns full of women and wine.

When eccentric explorer, Lady Vincenza ‘Vintage’ de Grazon, offers him employment, he sees an easy way out. Even when they are joined by a fugitive witch with a tendency to set things on fire, the prospect of facing down monsters and retrieving ancient artefacts is preferable to the abomination he left behind.

But not everyone is willing to let the Eboran empire collapse, and the adventurers are quickly drawn into a tangled conspiracy of magic and war. For the Jure’lia are coming, and the Ninth Rain must fall…

Book Review:

I received a free copy of this book courtesy of the publisher through bookbridgr in exchange for an honest review.

Ebora was once a vast and affluent city, now it is a desolate and unkempt area populated by the few remaining Eborans with the streets stalked by wolves. Eborans are long living with a life span upwards of 500 years, aided in keeping their youth and virulence by the sap from their tree god Ygseril.

Throughout the ages and generations Sarn has been attacked by the Jure’lia (the worm people). Each time that the Jure’lia have waged an invasion attempt on Sarn, the Eboran Empire has come to the aid of the humans and the defence of Sarn. Every war and invasion by the Jure’lia and their Behemoths has been countered by a ‘Rain’ from the Eboran tree god Ygseril, the rain in question being a rainfall of massive pods grown amongst the branches and leaves of Ygseril, from these pods are birthed massive Eboran mythical war-beasts to combat and repel the Jure’lia threat and each time they have succeeded up until the last rain, The Eight Rain.

At the end of The Eighth Rain, the Jure’lia queen vanished and Ygseril died. Now, for many years the Eboran tree god has lain dormant, unheeding to the Eborans pleas, with no sap to aid their longevity the Eborans turned to human blood however they paid a price, for with their penchant and need for human blood came the crimson flux, a disease that decimated the Eboran Empire and dwindled their numbers to barely a few.

Years have passed since The Eighth Rain, the Jure’lia are thought gone, the only remnants of them the remains of the crashed Behemoths left over from the previous Rains that are strewn across Sarn.

With Ebora a shadow of its former self Tormalin the Oathless leaves the crumbling streets, the shadow of the crimson flux and his sister Hestillion behind to flit away his days partaking in drunken debauchery (he likes his wine, glug glug). On his travels he finds work as a hired sword with the explorer Lady Vincenza ‘Vintage’ de Grazon who has a fascination with the Jure’lia and the Behemoth remains, researching them and their secrets in her search for and pursuit of knowledge.

Along their travels the pair are joined by the Fell-Witch, Fell-Noon who has escaped from a decade of imprisonment in The Winnowry (Fell-witches are able to use winnowfire by drawing on life essence and due to this are deemed bad, vilified for their powers) and is now being hunted by an agent of The Winnowry and thus are trio of main characters are formed.

For the most part we focus on and follow the adventures and escapades of Vintage, Tor and Noon as they hunt and excavate the various Behemoth remains with a few visits to Ebora, Hestillion and her fixation with Ygseril thrown into the mix.

You know me and my blog by now and as such know that I’m not one to go into and give you long and elaborate explanations, detailing every aspect of the story, a book is a journey that you need to experience for yourself.

Suffice to say that the fruits of attempting to bring life back to Ygseril, the secrets hidden within the behemoth remains and the Jure’lia will all be revealed and what was lost and dormant will once again awaken and re-emerge, culminating in The Ninth Rain falling and the proverbial shit hitting the fan.

It took me a while to get into The Ninth Rain, from the start you are greeted with engaging characters and an intriguing premise, particularly with the parasite spirits that haunt the Behemoth remains. But to begin with it was just a book that I was reading and not a must-read – sorry Jen.

On occasion a book being a must-read from the very beginning can at times be detrimental to the overall story being told, you miss out on the ‘hook’ that singular moment when you are unwittingly pulled in, finding yourself loving the book.

For those unaware what a hook is, the actual ‘hook’ is the moment in a book that changes how you perceive it. The hook itself could be something massive that impacts the story in a huge way or something small and trivial with no overall effect on the story, a simple exchange between characters.

The hook will be different for each individual reader, it is that feeling you get when a book goes from being something you are simply ‘just reading’ to a ‘must-read page turner’ of a novel. It is an awesome experience, something to savour and that’s what happened with me and The Ninth Rain, after 50 pages I was completely hooked.

I can actually tell you exactly where it happened, that moment when I become fully immersed and invested in the story Williams was telling and from then on couldn’t put the book down. It wasn’t a story defining event of great importance, no, it was a just a simple exchange between Tor and Vintage. Vintage had me sniggering away and it was then that I realised she was a character I could really dig – get it, explorers ‘dig’ for buried artifacts! πŸ™‚

‘Vintage!’ Tor put on his most outraged expression, and pulled the sheets around his waist. ‘This really is unacceptable. Unacceptable. How dare you interrupt -‘.

‘Darling, if I had to wait for you to voluntarily leave this good woman’s bed, I’d be waiting until the Tenth Rain. And stop clutching at yourself like a maiden, you’ve nothing I haven’t seen before.’

At the beginning of lots of the chapters you find excerpts from the correspondence and letters of Vintage, these are wonderfully informative additions adding extra layers and hints to the story and are a joy to read, giving you both a sneak peek into Vintage’s time before The Ninth Rain takes place and as a plot device to elaborate on the history of Sarn.

Williams has created a fully fleshed landscape with Mushenska and Sarn, steeped in history and lore it’s a living and breathing world that is brought to life by Williams writing. Revealing and explaining enough to draw you in she also leaves plenty left unsaid for elaboration in future books. With the locations used in the book Williams paints a vivid picture The Winnowry is an ominous, dank and dark place, you feel the once majesty of Ebora now gone to ruin and the wild with its overgrown vegetation and wildlife are all easy to imagine.

The trio of main characters are a great choice for the story to revolve around – (the important secondary characters are also all well realised). Each of the three main characters are individual in their own right but together the interplay and banter between them is second to none. All three are given plenty of fantastic lines and page time to shine. Tor is sarcastic with quips to spare and during the journey Noon transforms from the shy and reticent escapee to a dogged character coming into her own.

The star of the show however has to be Vintage, such a quirky character compared to the stereotypical norm, she is a middle-aged explorer and scholar, exuding charisma and personality each and every time she is on the page. Plucky and full of gumption with a heart of gold, she’s also a dab hand with the crossbow and has an eccentric and kooky persona, nothing gets in her way and she personifies determined.

There’s plenty of unique and original ideas sprinkled throughout the pages of The Ninth Rain, along with the unorthodox Vintage, you have the vampiresque Eborans, the Jure’lia, the parasite spirits with their lights, fronds and shifting gelatinous shapes that haunt the Behemoth remains and giant flying bats!

Lots of stand-out moments are found in The Ninth Rain and one of my favourites had to be the reveal of the true origins of the parasite spirits late on in the book. While reading I hadn’t guessed it, with what had occurred in the story I was unsure about the intentions of certain presences and when they did finally come to light, I thought the resulting disclosure was sublimely done by Williams.

My only gripe with The Ninth Rain, it has nothing to do with the story, writing or anything else that is included inside the pages, all that is top quality. It’s something that isn’t included, a trivial thing of little importance that might seem miserly but it niggled me, there is no map of Sarn in the book. I like my maps in fantasy books, when a story takes place over vast miles and various areas it’s nice to see a map depicting the world, it helps you picture the epic scope and scale of the created world.

Great pacing, top-notch writing, quality characterisation, plenty of action, fire – burn baby burn! Emotion, humour with a smidgen of romance added to the equation all make The Ninth Rain a truly enjoyable and absorbing read, come the final page you are left wanting more.

Fueled by winnowfire, The Ninth Rain is a flame that burns brightly as an exceptional start to a brand new fantasy trilogy.

Highly recommended.


Amazon UK Β / Β Amazon US Β / Β The Book Depository


Follow The Tattooed Book Geek on:

Twitter,Β Goodreads, Blog Facebook, Personal Facebook.


30 thoughts on “The Ninth Rain (The Winnowing Flame #1) Book Review

  1. C’mon now Drew , you are being too picky with the Map thing, I mean remember even First Law series didn’t have a map .

    Fantastic review , story gives me a feel of a Mixture between Malazan empire meets Dune’s Worm … I’m putting it in my TBR for now πŸ™‚

    Liked by 1 person

  2. You are my #1 blogger source for Fantasy in the epic proportions Drewski. I started reading your review thinking it may have not been a win but see what you did there lol. I love that moment…”the hook” It feels like sparks go off & was probably the 1st indicator for me that books are my drug of choice. Vintage sounds like my type of gal, adding to my TBR if only to meet this quirky lady!

    P.S. a good map does go a long way in aiding that imagination πŸ˜‰

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Yes, maps rule! I think it’s more to do with the fact that in most fantasy books there is a map so when you don’t get one in the book, you miss it and wonder where it is.πŸ˜‚

      Vintage is awesome, definitely not stereotypical for the genre but a quirky and fun character.

      Ha, yeah, I wasn’t sure for the first 50 pages but then it certainly turned into a win, a fantastic read.πŸ˜€


  3. Highest quality review as usual good sir πŸ˜‰ Love that you took the time to share the moment that hooked you. Always interesting to compare (which I will if I read) since reading is so individualized and as you mentioned personal. I think I have glanced over this one a few times out of curiosity. Will make my TBR no doubt with your recommendation.

    I do have a question about the tree god amd the sap to maintain their longevity.. is this similar to Shannara Chronicles or am I mistaken? Sounds vaguely familar but I have not read that series? Have you? I could be way off the mark and just remembering something about a tree haha.

    I will admit that the lack of map is quite disappointing. Call me spoiled, but maps are a must with expansive fantasy ☺

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Yes! Maps! Most fantasy books have them so when one doesn’t it is missed.πŸ˜€

      No, not read Shannara chronicles but watched the TV show and it does have a tree, not sure about the sap bit though, think the leaves hold the bad guys hostage and when one falls it releases the bad guy. I remember in the TV show that when the last leaf fell it released the big bad.

      So, I guess there is a similarly but the tree is called Ygseril and the Norse tree is called Ygdrasil so there’s another similarity to, then again Ygdrasil is also used in The Long War series so you do get the occasional overlap with world trees.πŸ˜€

      Definitely think it’s a book that you’d enjoy.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. If you are in favor of it, I know that I will enjoy it πŸ™‚ You seem to be spot on with fantasy for sure. Unfortunately, I still have a few odd and end books to review. Now that I have kicked into fantasy mode, it is hard to pick them up. But I made commitments so I must.. le sigh.

        Liked by 1 person

  4. Yay! Finally did my review and was able to come and read yours… and I must say, you did a way better job at it! haha.. I found it so difficult to start from anywhere to even try and explain anything because the book blow my mind in a good way πŸ˜‰

    I love that we both pointed out some similar things.. I also enjoyed the story behind parasite spirits and Vintage/Tor dynamics…

    Mega, just mega, review Drew.. sorry it took me so long to come and read your masterpiece! πŸ˜‰

    Liked by 1 person

    1. No worries, the Queen arrives when she wants! πŸ™‚

      I think we both did a great job reviewing the book, we all review differently and in our own unique way. It is often hard to know where to start with fantasy books and explaining what happens as often so much happens and some of it would give the story away, hence why I only glaze over the story involved so as not to spoil anything. πŸ™‚ here’s to the sequel! πŸ™‚

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Hahaha… keep calling me queen and I’ll start to believe it. Might even develop a massive chip on my shoulder,aye!
        Cheers- here’s to the sequel! πŸ˜‰


    1. Thank you.πŸ˜€ Haven’t read that book, I just like maps in fantasy books, it helps with the scope and scale when the characters have to travel somewhere or they get somewhere that is 1000’s of miles away in a matter of days and I can refer to the map.πŸ˜‚ It just seemed weird there being no map as most fantasy books seem to have them.

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.